The Controversy Surrounding JAMstack and WordPress
Unveiling the Power of JAMstack
Advantages and Disadvantages of JAMstack
The Dominance of WordPress
A Comparative Analysis
In the digital realm, the clash of opinions between celebrities, politicians, or sports figures can instantly become global news. However, when the debate revolves around web development technologies, such as JAMstack and WordPress, it often goes unnoticed by the masses. Despite its lack of mainstream attention, this ongoing discussion holds significant relevance within the developer’s ecosystem. Even when WordPress co-founder Matt Mullenweg shared his views on JAMstack in an email to Richard MacManus, it failed to garner the attention it deserved.
“JAMstack is a regression for the vast majority of the people adopting it; the usability and functionalities are actually lower. Even rebuilding sites in JAMstack harkens back to the Movable Type days, where the bigger your site gets, the slower it is to rebuild or update templates.” – Matt Mullenweg, WordPress Co-Founder
This critique from Matt Mullenweg triggered an inevitable backlash. Eder-Pressman, Stackbit’s co-founder and CEO, was one of the first to respond:
“The achievements of WordPress in terms of market share and how it democratized early web publishing are amazing. When it comes to architecture, I think it was best in class for the early 2000s, but it’s time to move forward. We already see cohorts of websites where Jamstack adoption crosses 20% – it’s no longer a question of if the Jamstack becomes the predominant architecture for the web but a question of when. The cliche is a cliche but it also rings true – First, they ignore you, then they laugh at you (we are here), then you win.”
Eder-Pressman concurred with Matt Mullenweg on JAMstack’s usability and functionality limitations but emphasized its architecture’s resilience.
Another prominent figure in this debate is Mathias Biilmann, CEO of Netlify, who coined the term ‘JAMstack’:
“There’s often a moment right around the time when an old technology is about to be displaced by the next thing, where the main leader in the field goes out and makes a strong argument that absolutely nothing is happening. A moment that ends up looking like a turning point where the new was undeniably present enough to be worth being in denial about.”
Before delving into this debate, let’s first explore the core attributes of JAMstack and WordPress.
JAMstack connects these elements to empower web developers in crafting exceptional websites:
The User Experience of JAMstack and What Happens at the Backend:
Major Benefits of JAMstack:
JAMstack offers numerous advantages, including speed, security, and an efficient development workflow. Moreover, it eliminates the need to manage a backend server or database. Since system administrators generate web pages, security against code injection is robust.
However, despite these advantages, the technology faces criticism, especially from WordPress’s co-founder and CEO, Matt Mullenweg.
Disadvantages of JAMstack:
JAMstack is most suitable for small websites that do not require frequent template rebuilding, unlike WordPress. As the site’s size increases, the maintenance and rebuilding of static pages become more challenging, negating the initial speed advantage.
WordPress, along with other content management systems like Magento, Joomla, Drupal, and Shopify, specializes in creating dynamic websites. These platforms fetch complete PHP pages, which are more substantial than static HTML pages.
WordPress’s user-friendly interface allows non-developers to create, edit, and publish content effortlessly. Additionally, it supports various plugins to enhance functionality. However, this convenience comes at a cost. WordPress retrieves pages from a database, consuming substantial resources and making it a more resource-intensive option compared to JAMstack.
In contrast, static site generators used in JAMstack load pre-generated HTML pages instantly. Articles are created, transformed into HTML pages, and placed on a server directory. When a visitor accesses the page, it directly retrieves the pre-generated content without establishing a new connection each time. This approach significantly reduces the time required, particularly for managing interrelated pages.
The static site generator approach excels in creating static pages quickly with minimal server resources, making it efficient for websites with numerous interconnected pages. In contrast, WordPress’s dynamic approach is more suitable for content that frequently changes, such as news feeds and shopping cart pages. WordPress also boasts a vast community and an extensive collection of apps and plugins, simplifying complex functionalities.
While JAMstack offers benefits in terms of speed, security, and development workflow, it faces limitations with larger websites and dynamic content. WordPress, on the other hand, remains a user-friendly and versatile choice, particularly for those without extensive technical knowledge.
In conclusion, the debate between JAMstack and WordPress continues, with each technology possessing its strengths and weaknesses. The choice between the two depends on specific project requirements, technical expertise, and the goals of web developers and content creators.
In the realm of iOS and Android app development, the usual suspects are Objective-C, Swift, and Java. However, there’s a contender that often flies under the radar—Xamarin. This article dives deep into the world of Xamarin, conducting a thorough review and comparing it to both native and cross-platform mobile development solutions available in the market.Read more
In the ever-evolving landscape of mobile app development, developers are constantly seeking efficient tools that streamline their workflow. Xamarin, however, has emerged as a controversial choice for many developers. Having worked with Xamarin for the past seven months, I’ve encountered numerous challenges and pitfalls that make it less than ideal for modern app development. TL;DR:Read more
The Ever-Present Java: Navigating Its Landscape in 2023 Introduction Java, a stalwart in the programming world, has not only weathered the storm of technological evolution but continues to thrive as one of the most widely used languages globally. As we approach 2023, it’s imperative to delve into the current state of Java, analyzing its positionRead more